Quantifying the impact of initial RNA primer length on nucleotide addition by RNA polymerase I.

Transient state kinetic studies of eukaryotic DNA-dependent RNA polymerases (Pols) in vitro provide quantitative characterization of enzyme activity at the level of individual nucleotide addition events. Previous work revealed heterogeneity in the rate constants governing nucleotide addition by yeast RNA polymerase I (Pol I) for each position on a template DNA. In contrast, the rate constants that described nucleotide addition by yeast RNA polymerase II (Pol II) were more homogeneous. This observation led to the question, what drives the variability of rate constants governing RNA synthesis by Pol I? Are the kinetics of nucleotide addition dictated by the position of the nascent RNA within the polymerase or by the identity of the next encoded nucleotide? In this study, we examine the impact of nucleotide position (i.e. nascent RNA primer length) on the rate constants governing nine sequential nucleotide addition events catalyzed by Pol I. The results reveal a conserved trend in the observed rate constants at each position for all primer lengths used, and highlight that the 9-nucleotide, or 9-mer, RNA primer provides the fastest observed rate constants. These findings suggest that the observed heterogeneity of rate constants for RNA synthesis by Pol I in vitro is driven primarily by the template sequence.

The A12.2 Subunit Plays an Integral Role in Pyrophosphate Release of RNA Polymerase I.

RNA polymerase I (Pol I) synthesizes ribosomal RNA (rRNA), which is the first and rate-limiting step in ribosome biosynthesis. A12.2 (A12) is a critical subunit of Pol I that is responsible for activating Pol I's exonuclease activity. We previously reported a kinetic mechanism for single-nucleotide incorporation catalyzed by Pol I lacking the A12 subunit (ΔA12 Pol I) purified from S. cerevisae and revealed that ΔA12 Pol I exhibited much slower incorporation compared to Pol I. However, it is unknown if A12 influences each nucleotide incorporation in the context of transcription elongation. Here, we show that A12 contributes to every repeating cycle of nucleotide addition and that deletion of A12 results in an entirely different kinetic mechanism compared to WT Pol I. We found that instead of one irreversible step between each nucleotide addition cycle, as reported for wild type (WT) Pol I, the ΔA12 variant requires one reversible step to describe each nucleotide addition. Reversibility fundamentally requires slow PPi release. Consistently, we show that Pol I is more pyrophosphate (PPi) concentration dependent than ΔA12 Pol I. This observation supports the model that PPi is retained in the active site of ΔA12 Pol I longer than WT Pol I. These results suggest that A12 promotes PPi release, revealing a larger role for the A12.2 subunit in the nucleotide addition cycle beyond merely activating exonuclease activity.

Protocol for monitoring and analyzing single nucleotide incorporation by S. cerevisiae RNA polymerases.

Here we present an optimized protocol for monitoring and analyzing single nucleotide incorporation by RNA polymerases. This protocol describes the assembly of Saccharomyces cerevisiae RNA polymerase I elongation complexes in a promoter-independent system in vitro. We describe how to collect a time course using a quench-flow, a rapid mixing instrument, and subsequently resolve reactions on a polyacrylamide gel. Finally, we detail how to quantify the gel images. For complete details on the use and execution of this protocol, please refer to Appling et al. (2015).1.

The cofactor-dependent folding mechanism of Drosophila cryptochrome revealed by single-molecule pulling experiments.

The link between cofactor binding and protein activity is well-established. However, how cofactor interactions modulate folding of large proteins remains unknown. We use optical tweezers, clustering and global fitting to dissect the folding mechanism of Drosophila cryptochrome (dCRY), a 542-residue protein that binds FAD, one of the most chemically and structurally complex cofactors in nature. We show that the first dCRY parts to fold are independent of FAD, but later steps are FAD-driven as the remaining polypeptide folds around the cofactor. FAD binds to largely unfolded intermediates, yet with association kinetics above the diffusion-limit. Interestingly, not all FAD moieties are required for folding: whereas the isoalloxazine ring linked to ribitol and one phosphate is sufficient to drive complete folding, the adenosine ring with phosphates only leads to partial folding. Lastly, we propose a dCRY folding model where regions that undergo conformational transitions during signal transduction are the last to fold.

Transient-State Kinetic Analysis of the RNA Polymerase II Nucleotide Incorporation Mechanism.

Eukaryotic RNA polymerase II (Pol II) is an essential enzyme that lies at the core of eukaryotic biology. Due to its pivotal role in gene expression, Pol II has been subjected to a substantial number of investigations. We aim to further our understanding of Pol II nucleotide incorporation by utilizing transient-state kinetic techniques to examine Pol II single nucleotide addition on the millisecond time scale. We analyzed Saccharomyces cerevisiae Pol II incorporation of ATP or an ATP analog, Sp-ATP-α-S. Here we have measured the rate constants governing individual steps of the Pol II transcription cycle in the presence of ATP or Sp-ATP-α-S. These results suggest that Pol II catalyzes nucleotide incorporation by binding the next cognate nucleotide and immediately catalyzes bond formation and bond formation is either followed by a conformational change or pyrophosphate release. By comparing our previously published RNA polymerase I (Pol I) and Pol I lacking the A12 subunit (Pol I ΔA12) results that we collected under the same conditions with the identical technique, we show that Pol II and Pol I ΔA12 exhibit similar nucleotide addition mechanisms. This observation indicates that removal of the A12 subunit from Pol I results in a Pol II like enzyme. Taken together, these data further our collective understanding of Pol II's nucleotide incorporation mechanism and the evolutionary divergence of RNA polymerases across the three domains of life.

RNA Polymerase I Is Uniquely Vulnerable to the Small-Molecule Inhibitor BMH-21.

Cancer cells require robust ribosome biogenesis to maintain rapid cell growth during tumorigenesis. Because RNA polymerase I (Pol I) transcription of the ribosomal DNA (rDNA) is the first and rate-limiting step of ribosome biogenesis, it has emerged as a promising anti-cancer target. Over the last decade, novel cancer therapeutics targeting Pol I have progressed to clinical trials. BMH-21 is a first-in-class small molecule that inhibits Pol I transcription and represses cancer cell growth. Several recent studies have uncovered key mechanisms by which BMH-21 inhibits ribosome biosynthesis but the selectivity of BMH-21 for Pol I has not been directly measured. Here, we quantify the effects of BMH-21 on Pol I, RNA polymerase II (Pol II), and RNA polymerase III (Pol III) in vitro using purified components. We found that BMH-21 directly impairs nucleotide addition by Pol I, with no or modest effect on Pols II and III, respectively. Additionally, we found that BMH-21 does not affect the stability of any of the Pols' elongation complexes. These data demonstrate that BMH-21 directly exploits unique vulnerabilities of Pol I.

Uncovering the mechanisms of transcription elongation by eukaryotic RNA polymerases I, II, and III.

Eukaryotes express three nuclear RNA polymerases (Pols I, II, and III) that are essential for cell survival. Despite extensive investigation of the three Pols, significant knowledge gaps regarding their biochemical properties remain because each Pol has been evaluated independently under disparate experimental conditions and methodologies. To advance our understanding of the Pols, we employed identical in vitro transcription assays for direct comparison of their elongation rates, elongation complex (EC) stabilities, and fidelities. Pol I is the fastest, most likely to misincorporate, forms the least stable EC, and is most sensitive to alterations in reaction buffers. Pol II is the slowest of the Pols, forms the most stable EC, and negligibly misincorporated an incorrect nucleotide. The enzymatic properties of Pol III were intermediate between Pols I and II in all assays examined. These results reveal unique enzymatic characteristics of the Pols that provide new insights into their evolutionary divergence.

AAA+ proteins: one motor, multiple ways to work.

Numerous ATPases associated with diverse cellular activities (AAA+) proteins form hexameric, ring-shaped complexes that function via ATPase-coupled translocation of substrates across the central channel. Cryo-electron microscopy of AAA+ proteins processing substrate has revealed non-symmetric, staircase-like hexameric structures that indicate a sequential clockwise/2-residue step translocation model for these motors. However, for many of the AAA+ proteins that share similar structural features, their translocation properties have not yet been experimentally determined. In the cases where translocation mechanisms have been determined, a two-residue translocation step-size has not been resolved. In this review, we explore Hsp104, ClpB, ClpA and ClpX as examples to review the experimental methods that have been used to examine, in solution, the translocation mechanisms employed by AAA+ motor proteins. We then ask whether AAA+ motors sharing similar structural features can have different translocation mechanisms. Finally, we discuss whether a single AAA+ motor can adopt multiple translocation mechanisms that are responsive to different challenges imposed by the substrate or the environment. We suggest that AAA+ motors adopt more than one translocation mechanism and are tuned to switch to the most energetically efficient mechanism when constraints are applied.

Multi-start Evolutionary Nonlinear OpTimizeR (MENOTR): A hybrid parameter optimization toolbox.

Parameter optimization or "data fitting" is a computational process that identifies a set of parameter values that best describe an experimental data set. Parameter optimization is commonly carried out using a computer program utilizing a non-linear least squares (NLLS) algorithm. These algorithms work by continuously refining a user supplied initial guess resulting in a systematic increase in the goodness of fit. A well-understood problem with this class of algorithms is that in the case of models with correlated parameters the optimized output parameters are initial guess dependent. This dependency can potentially introduce user bias into the resultant analysis. While many optimization programs exist, few address this dilemma. Here we present a data analysis tool, MENOTR, that is capable of overcoming the initial guess dependence in parameter optimization. Several case studies with published experimental data are presented to demonstrate the capabilities of this tool. The results presented here demonstrate how to effectively overcome the initial guess dependence of NLLS leading to greater confidence that the resultant optimized parameters are the best possible set of parameters to describe an experimental data set. While the optimization strategies implemented within MENOTR are not entirely novel, the application of these strategies to optimize parameters in kinetic and thermodynamic biochemical models is uncommon. MENOTR was designed to require minimal modification to accommodate a new model making it immediately accessible to researchers with a limited programming background. We anticipate that this toolbox can be used in a wide variety of data analysis applications. Prototype versions of this toolbox have been used in a number of published investigations already, as well as ongoing work with chemical-quenched flow, stopped-flow, and molecular tweezers data sets. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Non-linear least squares (NLLS) is a common form of parameter optimization in biochemistry kinetic and thermodynamic investigations These algorithms are used to fit experimental data sets and report corresponding parameter values. The algorithms are fast and able to provide good quality solutions for models involving few parameters. However, initial guess dependence is a well-known drawback of this optimization strategy that can introduce user bias. An alternative method of parameter optimization are genetic algorithms (GA). Genetic algorithms do not have an initial guess dependence but are slow at arriving at the best set of fit parameters. Here, we present MENOTR, a parameter optimization toolbox utilizing a hybrid GA/NLLS algorithm. The toolbox maximizes the strength of each strategy while minimizing the inherent drawbacks.

Transient-state kinetic analysis of multi-nucleotide addition catalyzed by RNA polymerase I.

RNA polymerases execute the first step in gene expression: transcription of DNA into RNA. Eukaryotes, unlike prokaryotes, express at least three specialized nuclear multisubunit RNA polymerases (Pol I, Pol II, and Pol III). RNA polymerase I (Pol I) synthesizes the most abundant RNA, ribosomal RNA. Nearly 60% of total transcription is devoted to ribosomal RNA synthesis, making it one of the cell's most energy consuming tasks. While a kinetic mechanism for nucleotide addition catalyzed by Pol I has been reported, it remains unclear to what degree different nucleotide sequences impact the incorporation rate constants. Furthermore, it is currently unknown if the previous investigation of a single-nucleotide incorporation was sensitive to the translocation step. Here, we show that Pol I exhibits considerable variability in both kmax and K1/2values using an in vitro multi-NTP incorporation assay measuring AMP and GMP incorporations. We found the first two observed nucleotide incorporations exhibited faster kmax-values (∼200 s-1) compared with the remaining seven positions (∼60 s-1). Additionally, the average K1/2 for ATP incorporation was found to be approximately threefold higher compared with GTP, suggesting Pol I has a tighter affinity for GTP compared with ATP. Our results demonstrate that Pol I exhibits significant variability in the observed rate constant describing each nucleotide incorporation. Understanding of the differences between the Pol enzymes will provide insight on the evolutionary pressures that led to their specialized roles. Therefore, the findings resulting from this work are critically important for comparisons with other polymerases across all domains of life.

The N-terminal domain of the A12.2 subunit stimulates RNA polymerase I transcription elongation.

Eukaryotes express three DNA-dependent RNA polymerases (Pols) that are responsible for the entirety of cellular genomic expression. The three Pols have evolved to express specific cohorts of RNAs and thus have diverged both structurally and functionally to efficiently execute their specific transcriptional roles. One example of this divergence is Pol I's inclusion of a proofreading factor as a bona fide subunit, as opposed to Pol II, which recruits a transcription factor, TFIIS, for proofreading. The A12.2 (A12) subunit of Pol I shares homology with both the Rpb9 subunit of Pol II as well as the transcription factor TFIIS, which promotes RNA cleavage and proofreading by Pol II. In this study, the functional contribution of the TFIIS-like C-terminal domain and the Rpb9-like N-terminal domain of the A12 subunit are probed through mutational analysis. We found that a Pol I mutant lacking the C-terminal domain of the A12 subunit (ΔA12CTD Pol I) is slightly faster than wild-type Pol I in single-nucleotide addition, but ΔA12CTD Pol I lacks RNA cleavage activity. ΔA12CTD Pol I is likewise similar to wild-type Pol I in elongation complex stability, whereas removal of the entire A12 subunit (ΔA12 Pol I) was previously demonstrated to stabilize transcription elongation complexes. Furthermore, the ΔA12CTD Pol I is sensitive to downstream sequence context, as ΔA12CTD Pol I exposed to AT-rich downstream DNA is more arrest prone than ΔA12 Pol I. These data demonstrate that the N-terminal domain of A12 does not stimulate Pol I intrinsic RNA cleavage activity, but rather contributes to core transcription elongation properties of Pol I.

Defining the divergent enzymatic properties of RNA polymerases I and II.

Eukaryotes express at least three nuclear DNA-dependent RNA polymerases (Pols) responsible for synthesizing all RNA required by the cell. Despite sharing structural homology, they have functionally diverged to suit their distinct cellular roles. Although the Pols have been studied extensively, direct comparison of their enzymatic properties is difficult because studies are often conducted under disparate experimental conditions and techniques. Here, we directly compare and reveal functional differences between Saccharomyces cerevisiae Pols I and II using a series of quantitative in vitro transcription assays. We find that Pol I single-nucleotide and multinucleotide addition rate constants are faster than those of Pol II. Pol I elongation complexes are less stable than Pol II elongation complexes, and Pol I is more error prone than Pol II. Collectively, these data show that the enzymatic properties of the Pols have diverged over the course of evolution, optimizing these enzymes for their unique cellular responsibilities.

Kinetic Analysis of AAA+ Translocases by Combined Fluorescence and Anisotropy Methods.

The multitude of varied, energy-dependent processes that exist in the cell necessitate a diverse array of macromolecular machines to maintain homeostasis, allow for growth, and facilitate reproduction. ATPases associated with various cellular activity are a set of protein assemblies that function as molecular motors to couple the energy of nucleoside triphosphate binding and hydrolysis to mechanical movement along a polymer lattice. A recent boom in structural insights into these motors has led to structural hypotheses on how these motors fulfill their function. However, in many cases, we lack direct kinetic measurements of the dynamic processes these motors undergo as they transition between observed structural states. Consequently, there is a need for improved techniques for testing the structural hypotheses in solution. Here, we apply transient-state fluorescence anisotropy and total fluorescence stopped-flow methods to the analysis of polypeptide translocation catalyzed by these ATPase motors. We specifically focus on the Hsp100-Clp protein system of ClpA, which is a well-studied, model ATPases associated with various cellular activity system that has both eukaryotic and archaea homologs. Using this system, we show that we can reproduce previously established kinetic parameters from the simultaneous analysis of fluorescence anisotropy and total fluorescence and overcome previous limitations of our previous approach. Specifically, for the first time, to our knowledge, we obtain quantitative interpretations of the translocation of polypeptide substrates longer than 100 aa.

Conformational plasticity of the ClpAP AAA+ protease couples protein unfolding and proteolysis.

The ClpAP complex is a conserved bacterial protease that unfolds and degrades proteins targeted for destruction. The ClpA double-ring hexamer powers substrate unfolding and translocation into the ClpP proteolytic chamber. Here, we determined high-resolution structures of wild-type Escherichia coli ClpAP undergoing active substrate unfolding and proteolysis. A spiral of pore loop-substrate contacts spans both ClpA AAA+ domains. Protomers at the spiral seam undergo nucleotide-specific rearrangements, supporting substrate translocation. IGL loops extend flexibly to bind the planar, heptameric ClpP surface with the empty, symmetry-mismatched IGL pocket maintained at the seam. Three different structures identify a binding-pocket switch by the IGL loop of the lowest positioned protomer, involving release and re-engagement with the clockwise pocket. This switch is coupled to a ClpA rotation and a network of conformational changes across the seam, suggesting that ClpA can rotate around the ClpP apical surface during processive steps of translocation and proteolysis.

Downstream sequence-dependent RNA cleavage and pausing by RNA polymerase I.

The sequence of the DNA template has long been thought to influence the rate of transcription by DNA-dependent RNA polymerases, but the influence of DNA sequence on transcription elongation properties of eukaryotic RNA polymerase I (Pol I) from Saccharomyces cerevisiae has not been defined. In this study, we observe changes in dinucleotide production, transcription elongation complex stability, and Pol I pausing in vitro in response to downstream DNA. In vitro studies demonstrate that AT-rich downstream DNA enhances pausing by Pol I and inhibits Pol I nucleolytic cleavage activity. Analysis of Pol I native elongating transcript sequencing data in Saccharomyces cerevisiae suggests that these downstream sequence elements influence Pol I in vivo Native elongating transcript sequencing studies reveal that Pol I occupancy increases as downstream AT content increases and decreases as downstream GC content increases. Collectively, these data demonstrate that the downstream DNA sequence directly impacts the kinetics of transcription elongation prior to the sequence entering the active site of Pol I both in vivo and in vitro.

Examination of the nucleotide-linked assembly mechanism of E. coli ClpA.

Escherichia coli ClpA is a AAA+ (ATPase Associated with diverse cellular Activities) chaperone that catalyzes the ATP-dependent unfolding and translocation of substrate proteins targeted for degradation by a protease, ClpP. ClpA hexamers associate with one or both ends of ClpP tetradecamers to form ClpAP complexes. Each ClpA protomer contains two nucleotide-binding sites, NBD1 and NBD2, and self-assembly into hexamers is thermodynamically linked to nucleotide binding. Despite a number of studies aimed at characterizing ClpA and ClpAP-catalyzed substrate unfolding and degradation, respectively, to date the field is unable to quantify the concentration of ClpA hexamers available to interact with ClpP for any given nucleotide and total ClpA concentration. In this work, sedimentation velocity studies are used to quantitatively examine the self-assembly of a ClpA Walker B variant in the presence of ATP. In addition to the hexamerization, we observe the formation of a previously unreported ClpA dodecamer in the presence of ATP. Further, we report apparent equilibrium constants for the formation of each ClpA oligomer obtained from direct boundary modeling of the sedimentation velocity data. The energetics of nucleotide binding to NBD1 and NBD2 are revealed by examining the dependence of the apparent association equilibrium constants on free nucleotide concentration.

Hsp104 and Potentiated Variants Can Operate as Distinct Nonprocessive Translocases.

Heat shock protein (Hsp) 104 is a hexameric ATPases associated with diverse cellular activities motor protein that enables cells to survive extreme stress. Hsp104 couples the energy of ATP binding and hydrolysis to solubilize proteins trapped in aggregated structures. The mechanism by which Hsp104 disaggregates proteins is not completely understood but may require Hsp104 to partially or completely translocate polypeptides across its central channel. Here, we apply transient state, single turnover kinetics to investigate the ATP-dependent translocation of soluble polypeptides by Hsp104 and Hsp104A503S, a potentiated variant developed to resolve misfolded conformers implicated in neurodegenerative disease. We establish that Hsp104 and Hsp104A503S can operate as nonprocessive translocases for soluble substrates, indicating a "partial threading" model of translocation. Remarkably, Hsp104A503S exhibits altered coupling of ATP binding to translocation and decelerated dissociation from polypeptide substrate compared to Hsp104. This altered coupling and prolonged substrate interaction likely increases entropic pulling forces, thereby enabling more effective aggregate dissolution by Hsp104A503S.

A Novel Assay for RNA Polymerase I Transcription Elongation Sheds Light on the Evolutionary Divergence of Eukaryotic RNA Polymerases.

Eukaryotic cells express at least three nuclear RNA polymerases (Pols), each with a unique set of gene targets. Though these enzymes are homologous, there are many differences among the Pols. In this study, a novel assay for Pol I transcription elongation was developed to probe enzymatic differences among the Pols. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, a mutation in the universally conserved hinge region of the trigger loop, E1103G, induces a gain of function in the Pol II elongation rate, whereas the corresponding mutation in Pol I, E1224G, results in a loss of function. The E1103G Pol II mutation stabilizes the closed conformation of the trigger loop, promoting the catalytic step, the putative rate-limiting step for Pol II. In single-nucleotide and multinucleotide addition assays, we observe a decrease in the rate of nucleotide addition and dinucleotide cleavage activity by E1224G Pol I and an increase in the rate of misincorporation. Collectively, these data suggest that Pol I is at least in part rate-limited by the same step as Pol II, the catalytic step.

ATP hydrolysis inactivating Walker B mutation perturbs E. coli ClpA self-assembly energetics in the absence of nucleotide.

E. coli ClpA is an AAA+ (ATPase Associated with diverse cellular Activities) chaperone that catalyzes the ATP-dependent unfolding and translocation of substrate proteins for the purposes of proper proteome maintenance. Biologically active ClpA hexamers contain two nucleotide binding domains (NBD) per protomer, D1 and D2. Despite extensive study, complete understanding of how the twelve NBDs within a ClpA hexamer coordinate ATP binding and hydrolysis to polypeptide translocation is currently lacking. To examine nucleotide binding and coordination at D1 and D2, ClpA Walker B variants deficient in ATP hydrolysis at one or both NBDs have been employed in various studies. In the presence of ATP, it is widely assumed that ClpA Walker B variants are entirely hexameric. However, a thermodynamically rigorous examination of the self-assembly mechanism has not been obtained. Differences in the assembly due to the mutation can be misattributed to the active NBD, leading to potential misinterpretations of kinetic studies. Here we use sedimentation velocity studies to quantitatively examine the self-assembly mechanism of ClpA Walker B variants deficient in ATP hydrolysis at D1, D2, and both NBDs. We found that the Walker B mutations had clear, if modest, effects on the assembly. Most notably, the Walker B mutation stabilizes the population of a larger oligomer in the absence of nucleotide, that is not present for analogous concentrations of wild type ClpA. Our results indicate that Walker B mutants, widely used in studies of AAA+ family proteins, require additional characterization as the mutation affects not only ATP hydrolysis, but also the ligand linked assembly of these complexes. This linkage must be considered in investigations of unfolding or other ATP dependent functions.

The A12.2 Subunit Is an Intrinsic Destabilizer of the RNA Polymerase I Elongation Complex.

Despite sharing a highly conserved core architecture with their prokaryotic counterparts, eukaryotic multisubunit RNA polymerases (Pols) have undergone structural divergence and biological specialization. Interesting examples of structural divergence are the A12.2 and C11 subunits of Pols I and III, respectively. Whereas all known cellular Pols possess cognate protein factors that stimulate cleavage of the nascent RNA, Pols I and III have incorporated their cleavage factors as bona fide subunits. Although it is not yet clear why these polymerases have incorporated their cleavage factors as subunits, a picture is emerging that identifies roles for these subunits beyond providing nucleolytic activity. Specifically, it appears that both A12.2 and C11 are required for efficient termination of transcription by Pols I and III. Given that termination involves destabilization of the elongation complex (EC), we tested whether A12.2 influences stability of the Pol I EC. Using, to our knowledge, a novel assay to measure EC dissociation kinetics, we have determined that A12.2 is an intrinsic destabilizer of the Pol I EC. In addition, the salt concentration dependence of Pol I EC dissociation kinetics suggests that A12.2 alters electrostatic interactions within the EC. Importantly, these data present a mechanistic basis for the requirement of A12.2 in Pol I termination. Combined with recent work demonstrating the direct involvement of A12.2 in Pol I nucleotide incorporation, this study further supports the concept that A12.2 cannot be viewed solely as a cleavage factor.